A panel is a group of people chosen to look at every idea while it is in a certain step. A reviewer is one person from that panel, picked by a collection manager to review one specific idea. When they are done, the reviewer clicks Mark as reviewed.
Who can do this: collection managers and Admins set up panels and assign reviewers. Panel members and reviewers can be any active members, Managers or Admins of the hive, but not guests or deactivated people.
Panels
Collection managers add a panel to a step in the step’s Step settings, under Panel. The Inbox can have a panel too, under Form & settings. See Adding and setting up steps.
While an idea is in their step, panel members:
- can see it, even if it is hidden from other members or the step hides its ideas
- get a notification and an email when an idea moves into their step. The email is headed Your input is needed and has a Review idea button.
- see a Waiting for you section on the idea, where they answer and rate the step’s questions and see everyone’s answers and scores, including who gave them. See Rating ideas and answering step questions.
- find the ideas waiting for them in My work, where they can work through them one at a time in a queue. See My work: everything that is waiting for you.
Moving an idea back to the Inbox sends no email to the Inbox panel. Once an idea leaves their step, panel members lose this extra access to it.
Panel members don’t get the collection’s Voting and Scoring views; those are for collection managers and Admins. Panel members don’t get any extra access to comments either. The list of who is on a panel is shown only to collection managers, Admins and the panel members themselves.
Turn on reviewers for a step
Reviewers only work on a step (or the Inbox) where a collection manager has turned on One reviewer per idea.
- Open the collection’s Manage view.
- Click the step in the sidebar and open the Step settings tab. For the Inbox, open Form & settings.
- Under Panel, click Add people (or Change) and add the people. Only panel members can be picked as reviewers.
- Under While ideas are here, turn on One reviewer per idea.
- Click Save.
When this is on, the reviewer box shows on every idea in that step. Collection managers see it on the idea’s Manage tab, in the step’s section. Panel members see it at the end of Waiting for you.
Assign a reviewer to an idea
- Open the idea and click the Manage tab. In the section for the step the idea is in, the reviewer box says No reviewer assigned.
- Click Assign reviewer.
- Pick a person from the list. The list shows the step’s panel members.
- Click Save. You see Reviewer assigned.
If the list is empty, the step has no panel yet. Add panel members in the step settings first.
To change the reviewer, click the reviewer’s name in the box and pick someone else. This starts the review again. To remove a reviewer who has not reviewed yet, click the × (Remove reviewer).
No notification or email is sent when you assign a reviewer, so let the person know. The review does show up in their My work.
Mark an idea as reviewed
If you are the assigned reviewer, the reviewer box at the end of Waiting for you shows Waiting to be reviewed, followed by your name. Being the reviewer doesn’t add anything to the step’s questions: you answer and rate them as a panel member, like the rest of the panel.
- Open the idea.
- In Waiting for you, click Mark as reviewed.
- Add a comment about your review. This is optional. Only the collection’s managers see it.
- Click Mark as reviewed again to confirm.
The box now shows Reviewed, your name and when you reviewed it, plus your comment.
Changed your mind? Click Undo. This also clears your comment.
Only the reviewer of the step the idea is in now can mark it as reviewed. When the idea moves to another step, the earlier review stays in its history and the new step starts without a reviewer.
Who sees the review
- Collection managers, Admins and the step’s panel see whether the idea has been reviewed, and by whom. Other members don’t see the reviewer box.
- The review comment is shown only to the reviewer, collection managers and Admins.
Panels compared with assignees
| Panel member | Reviewer | Assignee | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Set on | A step | One idea, at one step | One idea |
| Sees hidden ideas | While the idea is in their step | While the idea is in their step | Always |
| When an idea arrives at their step | None for being assigned | When assigned, plus step reminders | |
| Answers and rates step questions | Yes, while the idea is in their step | Only as a panel member | No |
| Can move the idea | No | No | No |
See Assigning people to an idea and adding contributors.