Help CenterSharing ideas

What happens after you submit an idea

Your idea lands in the collection’s Inbox. The collection managers look at new ideas there and move them through the collection’s steps, such as review, testing or implementation. You can follow your idea inside the idea itself, through notifications and emails, and find all your ideas on your profile.

The Inbox

Every new idea starts in the Inbox. Think of it as the collection’s in-tray. The collection managers read new ideas here and decide what happens next.

While your idea is in the Inbox:

  • other members can usually see it, like it and comment on it
  • you can still edit your answers
  • you can still delete it yourself. See How to edit or delete your idea.

Some collections hide ideas while they are in the Inbox. Then only you, the collection managers and a few others see your idea until it moves on. See Hidden ideas, hidden names and anonymous collections.

Steps and where your idea is

Steps are the stages an idea goes through after the Inbox. Each collection has its own steps, chosen by its managers. Some collections have no steps at all.

You can see where an idea is in these places:

  • On the idea’s card in the collection: a small chip at the bottom shows the step. Ideas in the Inbox have none. Hover over the chip, or tap it on a phone, to read the step’s description if the managers wrote one.
  • Inside the idea: the step chip sits above the title. An idea in the Inbox shows no step.
  • Where your idea is now: if you shared the idea, a section near the bottom lists every step in order. The current step is marked Now, with the date the idea got there and the step’s description. Tap another step to read its description.

Only collection managers and Admins can move it between steps. To learn how, see How to move an idea to another step.

Notifications you get

Open notifications from your profile picture > Notifications.

What happens Notification in Hives Email
Your idea moves to another step Yes: “{your idea} moved to {step}” Yes
Someone comments on your idea Yes Yes
Someone replies to your comment Yes Yes
Someone is assigned to your idea No No

The email about a new step has a View idea button. If the new step hides ideas from members, the email doesn’t name the step. It only says your idea has moved to a new stage. You are not told when you move an idea yourself.

You don’t get a notification when you submit, only the thank-you message. Collection managers may also have set up automatic comments that are posted when your idea arrives at a step. You see these as a notification in Hives, without an email.

There are no notification settings, so you can’t switch these emails off. See Notifications and emails from Hives.

Find your ideas again

  1. Click your profile picture in the top bar.
  2. Click Profile.
  3. Open the Contributions tab. It lists every idea in this hive that you shared or were added to as a contributor.

Click an idea to open it. If you have been made responsible for ideas, you find those under Assigned to me.

Ideas you submitted to an anonymous collection are not listed, because they are not linked to you.

Guests don’t have these lists on their profile. If you are a guest, open the collection from your link or invitation to see your ideas.

Step through ideas

When you open an idea from a list, the top of the idea shows where you are, for example “3 of 54”. Use the Previous idea and Next idea arrows, or the left and right arrow keys, to move through the list in its current order. The arrows don’t appear when you open an idea from a link or a notification.

  1. Open your idea.
  2. Click ⋯ (More actions) at the top right of the idea.
  3. Click Copy link. You see Link copied to clipboard.

You can also copy the address from your browser while the idea is open. Paste the link wherever you like. People who open it see the idea only if they have access to it.

Common questions

My idea hasn’t moved for a while. What should I do? Collection managers decide when ideas move on. Add a comment to your idea to ask about progress.

Can I move my idea to another step myself? No, unless you are also a collection manager or an Admin.

Why was my idea moved back to the Inbox? Collection managers can move an idea back to the Inbox. Ideas also go back there when the managers change or remove the collection’s steps. Ask a collection manager if you are unsure why.